4e’s skill challenges (while mathematically incredibly unsound and broken) had one good purpose:
You barely needed to prep between encounters. You could wing it as long as you kept track of skill results. Like the party is looking for a lich you prep the Lich Fight with minis and terrain and then as they walk in the city or forest looking for lich and asking people you improvise all of that and keep track of skill results throughout until you get to one of two outcomes both of which you can prep for. If you were good at winging it you saved prep time and made it still a playable game in some sense of the word.
But with OSR style prep you instead have a city or forest prepared through random tables and maps that you can just explore for real. No need for winging because they can really explore it for real. And no need for skill rolls either.
In a skill challenge the roll is necessary because you’re just hatpulling what’s in the desk until they either get to the Lich Fight combat scene or the Escape from Dungeon next skill challenge. But if you have written down what’s in the desk there’s no need for skill roll because you can just tell them what’s in the desk.
All that to say that I was disappointed in 5.5’s new “Study”, “Search” and “Influence” buttons. But I prefer those moments to be played through diegetically not press button to solve puzzle. PF2 and D&D 5.5 rightly acknowledges that we want a full game in between the battles but they wrongly make it a worst-of-both-worlds where you have OSR’s heavy prep requirements and 4e’s verfremdungseffective “button pressing” gameplay.