Idiomdrottning’s homepage

Vex & Sap destroy creativity

In 5.5 they introduced weapon masteries, most of which are fine but Vex and Sap grant advantage and imposes disadvantage respectively.

I don’t like that because I appreciated how in 5.0, advantage and disadvantage was reserved for fictional positioning and conditions. (Along with a handful of poorly designed spells that had slipped through somehow.)

Since advantage and disadvantage doesn’t stack, this means that this eats up a lot of reason for fighting creatively, like engaging with the environment, being downwind or having the sun in your back or luring them into tight corridors or what have you. Not asking for literary masterworks (a mistake I feel Wushu and Exalted both did, since they [albeit not exclusively] reward description skill on a textual level), just rewarding engaging with the diegesis in a freeform way. Being aware of what the room is like and what we can do in here.

This is also why I steered clear of the “flanking gives advantage” DMG variant. I thought it was gonna eat up fictional positioning.